I posted rather gloatingly a few months ago that Left Behind Video Games, publisher of the horrid Left Behind: Eternal Forces PC game, is not doing too well. Their stock is currently at about the same point - 10 to 20 cents per share - and they’ve lost $26,000,000 this year. I think the premise of the game and the company is deeply flawed, so I’m not shedding any tears over its poor performance, though I’m sure there are many good-hearted people who lost money on what they considered a faith-based investment, and that’s a shame.
That’s not the reason for this post, though. It appears that the company’s founders are still around and are keeping themselves busy not with publishing more video games, but with sicking their lawyer on people they don’t like. Today, I became one of those people.
I received two separate letters via certified mail telling me to remove this post and this post, as well as their comments. I’m not sure whether they found this post, in which I post Lyndon’s own words correcting some of the mischaracterizations that appeared in early reviews, which my post was based on. At any rate, they’re not happy I still have anti-Left Behind: Eternal Forces stuff on my site, and they sent me a nasty letter telling me to take it down.
It reads, in its entirety:
The Law Offices of Gordon D. Katz
452 Brookhurst Ave.
Narberth, PA 19144
PH: (610) 275-9000, Fax: (610) 672-9789
September 20, 2007
radicalcongruency.com
2907 S Byron St
Seattle, WA 98144
RE: False information posted on your site about the video game LEFT BEHIND: Eternal Forces
To whom this may concern:
I represent Left Behind Games Inc., the developer and publisher of the LEFT BEHIND series of video games. Your organization hosts a website that has information posted about this game. Unfortunately, there are many statements on your website which appear to be false and misleading. This type of misinformation may cause significant and irreparable harm to Left Behind Video Games Inc. and must be removed.
Left Behind Games Inc. generally supports free speech in the media and understands how important it is to have various opinions presented for public consumption. It will not, however, tolerate the publication of information regarding its products that is false or misleading.
Left Behind Games Inc. is demanding that you immediately remove any and all information contained on your site about the above stated game that is false and/or misleading, including any such statements or commentary and the responses thereto. This includes posted comments made by others in the context of reading the incorrect or misleading statements.
If you do not comply immediately, the company will be forced to pursue additional legal action which will include claims for damages, costs of suit and attorney’s fees. This may subject you and your organization to significant legal and financial damages.
If you need to discuss this further, please do not hesitate to contact my Administrator on this matter, Robilyn Lyndon at (951) 816-0901.
Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Very truly yours,
Gordon D. Katz, Esq.
I’m no lawyer, but I can play one on TV as well as the next guy, and I can tell this letter is nothing more than sore-loser bullying.
First off, I understand that LBG is not too happy their game got bad initial reviews, and they tried admirably to recover after the demo was released. Jeffrey Frichner, the company’s president, even left some comments here in his company’s defense. I listened carefully to what he and the newer reviews said, and responded at length here.
But you simply can’t go around suing people who say things about your product that you don’t like. All of the initial misinformation I posted on this site was corrected with follow-up information, which is easy to find by searching for Left Behind: Eternal Forces using the box at the top of the page.
What’s more, I made it very clear that I was speculating in much of what I said in my post, and I gave links to the sources I was using. There was no playable demo at the time, and when one became available, I posted my new findings. I did not, and will not, delete the original posts and comments, even if they don’t shed a good light on Left Behind: Eternal Forces.
Second, Mr. Katz, Left Behind Games does not publish a “series of video games.” There’s just one game, plus the expansion pack. I think you need more than one title, or at least a few games with the same name plus a roman numeral, to call it a series.
Third, Mr. Katz, you know very well that if we took this to court, your client would be the one to pay my legal fees, not vice-versa. If ever there was a frivolous lawsuit, this is it. The posts on this site are not slander, and not libel, and I have taken great pains to be fair as more information became available in this matter. If you can tell me exactly what basis you have for suing me, perhaps I will further consider your request.
Otherwise, stop bullying people with your fancy letterhead and get a client with a real case.