Our church has decided to stop meeting on Sundays, as I mentioned a few days ago. In the past week or so, I’ve been surprised at how there is a general sense among members that this also means the church is ceasing to exist, or that we have now failed in our efforts to plant a church.
We are continuing Film & Spirituality as well as our mid-week book discussion groups, which are currently focusing on How (Not) To Speak of God and The Great Divorce. So SMC is far from gone, and I consider it far from a failure.
However, I did underestimate how much it would feel like a failure to stop having our Sunday “service,” a term I despise because, well, I’m not a big fan of the idea of a weekly worship service. I never assumed we’d have a Sunday service for the long term, yet somehow we ended up with one.
Worship services are not easy for a small, leaderless group to pull off. For a long time, we didn’t really worry too much about the format, since we’re just a fairly small and informal group. A few months ago, though, when we had more people, we developed a liturgy to lend some consistency to our weekly gatherings.
More recently, without enough people to fill all the spots on the liturgy, it became difficult to sustain or see the value in this format, so we decided to stop doing it. While this has been deeply disturbing to our group, I think that’s a good thing, because it’s shaken us up and is forcing us to consider what it really means to be Christians in community. Here are some of my initial thoughts.
First, it’s time to stop doing things just because we always have. There’s no scriptural mandate to have a worship service, and if we’re bad at running it and not getting anything out of it, it’s time to find other ways to spend our time.
Second, it’s time to get beyond the idea of a church, a congregation, as a valid and discrete entity. There is only the church and groups that subdivide it. For too long, we’ve been subdivided but not connected to the other parts of the church in our area. We’ve taken Paul’s metaphor of the church as the body of Christ and shrunken it down so each congregation or gathering is the body, and everything outside that body is either a potential invader or an organ that’s been removed from the body.
If we’re to use Paul’s body metaphor correctly, we need to see the entire church as the body. Jesus’ messages to the seven churches in Revelation address the entire city as if it were one church, not many churches. I don’t know the congregational status of the Christians in these cities, but I’m guessing they didn’t all meet all at once, nor consider themselves separate, isolated congregations.
Third, we need to start seeing the church as a network of Christians in community and in relationship with each other. For the past five years, we’ve done very little networking or connecting with other Christians in our city. This past weekend at Off The Map Live, I got to see and catch up with several church planter friends, many of whom have left the church-planting business. As I spoke with people, I got the sense that, as Dwight Friesen said in a slightly different context, our best days are ahead of us. We’ve got a lot more thinking to do, and that thinking must include further development of trans-congregational ecclesiology.
As I said a few months back, it’s been a long while since I thought seriously about ecclesiology, probably because we’ve been spinning our wheels as a church and were getting to the point where we needed a shakeup. That shakeup as come, and now the thinking is coming fast and furious.
This past Sunday we had the pleasure of visiting The Ohana Project, a church started by some great people several years ago in a manner fairly similar to SMC. They meet in a community center and seem to be growing nicely, though they have observed that many people are not interested in coming every Sunday. Membership is much more fluid, and I think this reflects the network nature of the church as it is developing in Seattle.
I am eager to continue to think about these issues, visit with other Christians, and develop new ways for Seattle Metro Church to serve in our area. I also look forward to the ways we as a faith community and a group of friends can continue to enrich each other’s lives and faith.
The best is yet to come. Love to all.